A restaurant chef preparing a dish

Welcome to

Pauly's Pizza Joint

Serving up fresh, hand-tossed, New York pies straight out of the oven, at Pauly's we believe that quality food and customer service are the cornerstones to our business.

Order Online

Sign up for rewards

By providing your phone number, you are agreeing to participate in the rewards program and to be contacted through this number as part of the program. Rewards program information is subject to Toast's Terms of Service and Privacy Statement. Message and data rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Reply STOP to opt out.

Featured Items


  • Image

    Christmas Pie

    spinach, bacon, pepperoni, garlic, feta cheese (no sauce)

  • Image

    Pauly Walnuts

    pepperoni, sausage, bacon, fresh mushroom, red onion, green pepper, black olive

    (no walnuts)

  • Image

    Stromboli

    Baked Roll. pepperoni, mozzarella, ham, red onions, green peppers, Parmesan, garlic. served with side of marinara

1 / 2

Watch our

youtube video feature

customer testimonials

  • “Taste the difference"

    This place is the best, most underrated pizza joint in San Diego... it and watch the people that come through the doors and order, so you can see for yourself the love the local community has for this place and for owners Pauly, Mona and the pizza.

  • “Experience our Hospitality Today"

    Excellent pizza.  A classic New York pizza joint exactly how NY pizza should taste.  Huge slices.  High quality ingredients. Friendly service.  Price is right. 100 Stars!

  • “Food never disappoints”

    If you want to eat absolutely delicious pizza, hand made fresh with great care, look no further than Pauly's Pizza. I come here whenever I'm in the mood for a pie, and have brought many friends here to enjoy the pizza. The food never disappoints. The owners are honest, polite, salt of the earth people. I've eaten here many times, and will be back for many more.

1 / 2